ADR-002: Immediate Token Exchange in redirectToAuthorization()

Status: Superseded by ADR-006 (v3) Date: 2025-01-25 Tags: oauth, mcp, sdk-integration

Problem

The MCP SDK's auth() flow works as follows:

Check provider.tokens() — if valid tokens exist, return 'AUTHORIZED'
If no tokens, start authorization: call redirectToAuthorization(url)
Immediately return 'REDIRECT' (without re-checking tokens)

For web-based OAuth, this makes sense: redirectToAuthorization() triggers a page redirect and control never returns synchronously. The SDK expects authentication to complete in a subsequent request.

For CLI/desktop apps using browserAuth(), control does return synchronously—we capture the callback in-process via a local HTTP server. We exchange tokens inside redirectToAuthorization(), but the SDK has already decided to return 'REDIRECT', causing UnauthorizedError.

Decision

Exchange tokens inside redirectToAuthorization() and document the retry pattern as the expected usage:

typescript

// First connect triggers OAuth flow and saves tokens, but SDK returns
// 'REDIRECT' before checking. Second connect finds valid tokens.
async function connectWithOAuthRetry(client, serverUrl, authProvider) {
  const transport = new StreamableHTTPClientTransport(serverUrl, {
    authProvider,
  });
  try {
    await client.connect(transport);
  } catch (error) {
    if (error.message === "Unauthorized") {
      await client.connect(
        new StreamableHTTPClientTransport(serverUrl, { authProvider }),
      );
    } else throw error;
  }
}

Why a new transport on retry? The transport caches connection state internally. A fresh transport ensures clean reconnection.

Rationale

SDK constraint: No hook exists between redirect completion and the 'REDIRECT' return. The SDK interface (Promise<void>) cannot signal "auth completed."
In-process capture: CLI apps don't have page redirects that would trigger a fresh auth check cycle.
Correctness over elegance: The retry is unusual but reliable—tokens are always saved before the error.

Alternatives Considered

Alternative	Why Rejected
`transport.finishAuth(callbackUrl)`	Breaks provider encapsulation; doesn't fit in-process capture
Return tokens from `redirectToAuthorization()`	SDK interface expects `Promise<void>`
Upstream SDK change	Not viable for library consumers

Impact

Positive: Self-contained auth flow; no external coordination needed
Negative: First connection always throws UnauthorizedError after OAuth—must be documented clearly

ADR-002: Immediate Token Exchange in redirectToAuthorization() ​

Problem ​

Decision ​

Rationale ​

Alternatives Considered ​

Impact ​

Links ​